Sony FX6 vs Red Komodo vs Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF vs Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K vs Z Cam E2-F8. Which is the best deal for filmmakers?


Five cinema cameras. Only be one winner. Fight!

Cameras have become a lot better over the last few years. This means you can now own an amazing cinema camera for about $6,000 that can film a solid documentary, commercial, corporate video or short film or web series.

Which brings me to this article. I wanted to compare five cameras to see which is the best deal in filmmaking. Treat it as a fun comparison with currently available specs.

Here are the cameras compared:

  1. Sony FX6 (AmazonB&H)
  2. Red Komodo
  3. Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF
  4. Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H)
  5. Z Cam E2-F8

The camera body

Here’s how much the base camera body costs:

CameraPrice of Camera Body
Sony FX6$5,998
Red Komodo$5,995
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF$5,999
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K$6,385
Z Cam E2-F8$5,995

It would be in your best interest to feel out the after sales and service in your country or area prior to committing to any camera. No point buying a camera and then having to tear your hair out when you realize you have to ship your camera overseas for repair.

The price of the camera body is misleading, because some of the cameras on this list are ready to shoot, but others need a few accessories to get even. Read on, we’re going to look at this, too.

Remember, only one winner!

Comparison of sensors and video features

Sensor performance

Here’s how the camera sensors compare:

CameraMaximum ResolutionSensor Size
Sony FX64096 x 216035.7 x 18.8 mm
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF6016 x 398436 x 24 mm
Red Komodo6144 x 324027.03 x 14.25 mm
Z Cam E2-F88192 x 345635.97 x 23.98 mm
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K12,288 x 648027.03 x 14.25 mm

The Red Komodo and the Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H) have a Super 35mm sensor. The other cameras have full frame sensors. To know about the distinction read this:

https://website-39341349.tnb.awf.mybluehost.me/what-is-the-35mm-equivalent-and-why-is-it-confusing/

There is also quite a difference in maximum resolution. The advantage of a higher resolution on full frame cameras is you can crop to Super 35mm and still get 4K or higher. In this respect the Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF and the Z Cam E2-F8 have an advantage.

Let’s dig deeper:

CameraDynamic Range*ISO Range^Built-in NDShutter
Red Komodo16250 to 12,800NoGlobal
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF14+800, 5120NoRollling
Sony FX6#15+800, 12800 to 409,600Yes, 2-7 stopsRollling
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K14125 to 3200Yes 2, 4 and 6 stopsRollling
Z Cam E2-F814400, 1250NoRollling

*You can’t compare these dynamic range numbers directly because almost all of them fudge the numbers. None of these cameras beat the Arri Alexa LF with 14+ stops of dynamic range – not where it matters anyway!

#The Sony FX6 has 15+ stops dynamic range with 10% crop.

^The Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF, Sony FX6 and the Z Cam E2-F8 cameras have dual native ISO. The Red Komodo and the Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K don’t.

The Sony FX6 (AmazonB&H) is definitely the best camera for low light. It also has built-in ND filters. The USP of the Red Komodo is it is the only camera in this price range with a global shutter.

Frame rates

Let’s look at frame rates:

CameraMax fps at 4KMax fps at 1080p
Sony FX63840 x 2160 @ 120 fps*120 fps**
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF^ 3840 × 2160 @ 58 fps220 fps in S16 format | 112 fps in S35 format
Z Cam E2-F83840 × 2160 @ 60 fpsN/A
Red Komodo4096 x 2160 @ 60 fps120 fps
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K4096 x 2160 @ 120 fps | 240 fps in S16N/A

*In XAVC-S/L mode only, in UHD, not 4K DCI. In XAVC-I the maximum frame rate is 60 fps.

**The FX6 can do higher frame rates but less than 1080p resolution.

The Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H) seems to be the most versatile camera in this list for high frame rate recording.

You’ll also have to factor in the low light ability for HFR work. The more the frame rate, the more light you’ll need. Having a sensor with greater sensitivity is definitely an added advantage.

Codecs

CameraInternal RAWExternal RAW*Bit depth for RAWOther Codecs
Red KomodoRedcode RAWNo12-bitProres HQ (up to 4K)
Sony FX6No RAWProRes RAW via HDMI16-bit^XAVC-I
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12KBRAWNo12-bitNone
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFNo RAWNo12-bit 4:4:4:4 XQ
(no RAW)
Apple ProRes XQ
Z Cam E2-F8ZRAWProRes RAW via HDMI12-bitH.265 / H.264
*Externally using an Atomos Ninja V recorder
^Disregard the 16-bit bit depth on the Sony FX6, it’s probably just 12-bit rewrapped. It’s unlikely you’ll get true 16-bit for this price.

I’d give this to the Red Komodo. Redcode RAW is the most versatile RAW, accepted by almost all major NLEs. The ability to also shoot in Prores up to 4K is useful.

What you get externally:

CameraConnection (BNC)Best resolution and fpsAudio
Red Komodo12G SDI2160p @ 60fpsNone
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF3G-SDI x21080p @ 60fps2x XLR
Sony FX612G SDI x1, HDMI x14264 x 2408 @ 60fps | UHD @120 fps^2x XLR
Z Cam E2-F8HDMI x 15.8K @ 30 fps | 2160p @ 60fpsNone
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K12G-SDI x1, 3G-SDI x 12160p @ 60fps2x XLR
^120 fps requires an Atomos Ninja V+ recorder

One of the important distinctions of a cinema camera is the availability of additional SDI/HDMI ports for monitoring and recording.

In this regard the Sony FX6 (AmazonB&H) wins this for me, with XLR inputs and a frame rate of 120 fps if that’s what you need. The higher resolution is also useful if you need to crop or stabilize your footage. The Z Cam E2-F8 would have been decent except for the HDMI port.

Lenses

CameraMountsPrice for PL mount
Z Cam E2-F8EF mount (optional M, MFT, and PL mount accessory)$0
Sony FX6Sony E mount$369**
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12KPL (optional EF, F)$0
Red KomodoCanon RF$369**
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFActive PL Mount, Active E Mount, Native KineMOUNT$699*
*KineMOUNT costs $199, Active PL mount costs $699, Active E mount costs $599.
**I’ve assumed the Metabones PL to E mount adapter. Red does sell a $1,500 PL to RF adapter with mount.

I don’t think you’ll be restricted by the lens mount, though it must be mentioned the mark2 cameras support Active PL and E mounts. I’m not sure it makes complete sense in the case of PL. Why would anyone use a cheaper camera but still need accurate lens data? Wouldn’t the Edge 6K make more sense instead?

If your goal is to end up with PL glass you need to understand how the pricing changes. Some cameras have separate mounts you need to purchase and swap as needed, others don’t. For the latter you need adapters instead.

Overall, I feel the Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H) does best here by not overcharging unless you need additional mounts.

If you don’t need PL, then maybe autofocus is something you’re considering.

Autofocus performance

CameraContinuous Autofocus
Sony FX6 Phase Detection AF with Eye Tracking
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFNone
Red KomodoPDAF – Kindergarten Class
Z Cam E2-F8 AF exists
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12KNone

The Sony FX6 (AmazonB&H) autofocus wins hands down.

Monitoring and ergonomics

Weight and size

Let’s look at the weight and size:

CameraVolume (size)Weight (Body Only)
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K315 cubic inches2.55 kg
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF82.65 cubic inches1.37kg
Sony FX6 123 cubic inches890g
Red Komodo64 cubic inches952g
Z Cam E2-F873.50 cubic inches1.09kg (EF mount) / 1.16kg (PL mount)

The Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H) is large and heavy, but you need to consider the weight and size of additional accessories the other cameras need to arrive at the same functionality.

What about the LCD monitor? Some of the cameras have a monitor you can watch your footage on, and this is handy in a pinch. For serious monitoring, though, you need an external monitor that’s at least 5″, and none of the cameras have that.

All the cameras can be operated without a dedicated monitor or viewfinder.

CameraMonitor
Red Komodo2.9″ touchscreen
Sony FX63.5” touchscreen
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K4″ touchscreen
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFSize unknown, but it has a screen
Z Cam E2-F81.3″ (No touchscreen)

The Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H) has the biggest screen but the monitor on the Sony FX6 (AmazonB&H) can swivel in any direction. Overall I’d give this to the FX6.

Media and Batteries

Media

Here’s a look at the media options:

CameraCard slotsPrice (Price per GB)
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF^1x KineMAG Nano SSD$999 ($1 / 1 TB)
Red Komodo1x CFast 2.0*$479.99 ($0.93)
Sony FX62x CFexpress Type A** / SD card$1,048 ($1.63 / 640 GB)
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K2x CFast* / SD UHS-II + 1x USB-C 3.1 Gen 2$479.99 ($0.93)
Z Cam E2-F8 Full Frame 8K1x CFast 2.0*$479.99 ($0.93)
*SanDisk 512GB Extreme PRO CFast 2.0
^The KineMAG Nano is designed specifically for the Kinefinity Mavo cameras. It is an NVMe M.2 SSD with a capacity of 1 TB. 
**The largest size available currently is 640 GB.

There is a high-speed USB Type-C 3.1 Gen 2 port on the Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF and the Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H).

CameraBest Internal CodecData rate*Cost per 4 hours
Sony FX6*XAVC-I75 MB/s$1,719
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFProres XQ221 MB/s$3,108
Red KomodoRedcode RAW280 MB/s (175 MB/s)^$3,662 ($2,289)^
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12KBRAW578 MB/s (361 MB/s)^$7,559 ($4,721)^
Z Cam E2-F8ZRAW154 MB/s$2,014
*In the highest resolution and best compression setting. You’re not going to be buying a 12K or 6K camera to film in 4K.
^In 8:1 setting or MQ compression.

To be fair, I’m going to use the 8:1 and MQ compression settings to be on an even keel. You can see the Red Komodo‘s insane value when shooting in compressed RAW.

What about battery life?

Batteries and Power

CameraBatteryPower DrawBattery Voltage
Red KomodoBP-975 x 237 W14.4V
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFV-mount | BP-U27 W14.8V
Z Cam E2-F8Sony NP-F | 12V LEMO24 W**6.8-8.4V
Sony FX6Sony BP-U7018 W19.5V
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12KV-mount | Gold Mount55 W12V
**Based on the power consumption of the Z Cam E2-F6.

Now all we have to do is find the battery life and cost of operation for 6 hours of a day’s worth of work.

Here are the numbers:

CameraBattery life^Watt hoursCostCost of 6 hours of operation
Sony FX6210 mins72 Wh$320$549
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LF200 mins95 Wh$200$360
Red Komodo180 mins*106 Wh*$400*$800
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K100 mins95 Wh$200$720
Z Cam E2-F8110 mins45 Wh**$134$439
^Assuming a V-mount 95Wh battery when not mentioned.
*With two Canon BP-975 batteries.
**Assuming a Sony NP-F970 battery.

The Red Komodo draws a terrible amount of power for a camera that doesn’t have an LCD or viewfinder. Even the Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (Amazon, B&H) works out to be cheaper.

The Sony FX6 (AmazonB&H) is best overall with all the added accessories and functionaliy.

Time to sum up everything.

Which is cheaper to own?

Shall we? It’s important to add accessories to put all cameras on an even keel:

CameraRed KomodoSony FX6Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFBlackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12KZ Cam E2-F8 Full Frame 8K
Camera body$5,995$5,998$5,999$6,385$5,995
Cost of Media$2,289$1,719$3,108$4,721$2,014
Cost of Batteries$800$549$360$720$439
Lens Adapter$369$369$699$0$0
Total$9,453$8,635$10,166$11,826$8,448
To make it somewhat of a fair fight.

The price difference between the cheapest, the Z Cam E2-F8, and the most expensive, the Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K (AmazonB&H), is more than $3,300. That’s money you can use for other accessories, media, batteries or lenses.

The choice will come down to usability and exactly what kind of work you’re doing.

Verdict

First, a recap:

FeatureWinner
Sensor, ISO and Low LightSony FX6
Built-in ND filtersSony FX6
Frame RatesBlackmagic URSA 12K
CodecsRed Komodo
SDI and XLRSony FX6
Variety of LensesSony FX6
AutofocusSony FX6
MediaBlackmagic URSA 12K
ErgonomicsTie
Gimbal WeightSony FX6
Battery lifeSony FX6

I interact with thousands of filmmakers every year, and I can tell you: practical cinematography in the real world doesn’t really warrant anything better than what ny of these cameras are capable of producing. So the limitation will always be the cinematography and production values.

Before we take our final decision, we’ll let each camera tell us what it offers that the other doesn’t:

CameraUSPMajor Cons
Sony FX6Small and lightweight, low light performance, AF, full frame sensor, E-mount lenses, 4K 120 fps externally, ND filter, XLR inputs, production ready ergonomics, worldwide availability and supportNo RAW internally, no locking lens mount
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro 12K12K, 8K to 4K modes, 4″ LCD, production ready ergonomics, BRAW in many varieties of compression levels, high frame ratesLow light performance, size and power draw
Red KomodoGlobal shutter, 6K, Wireless, Hot swappable dual batteries, Internal compressed RAW, EthernetNo XLR for audio, power draw, no ND filter
Kinefinity Mavo mark2 LFFull frame sensor, XLR inputs, dual battery mounts, EthernetNo RAW internally, no ND filter
Z Cam E2-F88K, full frame sensor, EthernetZRAW is not a popular RAW format, No SDI, no locking mount

I promised one winner. If I had to pick one camera that can do everything, from documentaries to film work to even weddings, nothing beats the value of the Sony FX6 (AmazonB&H). It wins this comparison hands down.

If you really really need RAW, then I’d pick the Red Komodo.

What do you think?

Author Bio
Photo of author

Leave a Comment